SEC Regulation of Crypto Assets may exempt token sales up to 5 million dollars from registration but not from security status.
Executive Summary
The Securities and Exchange Commission’s Regulation Crypto Assets exempts token offerings up to 5 million dollars from registration, but the token remains a security under Howey. The Commission published the proposal in the Federal Register on August 21, 2026, docketed as Release Nos. 33-11434 and 34-106150, File No. S7-2026-27, with public comments due October 20, 2026.
A startup that stays under the offering cap can raise money through the Startup Exemption without filing a registration statement, and a larger issuer can raise as much as 20 million dollars in a Tier 1 offering or 75 million dollars in an audited Tier 2 offering under the companion Fundraising Exemption. Both exemptions excuse the transaction from registration, not the crypto asset from the definition of a security, so the antifraud and antimanipulation provisions of the Securities Act of 1933 and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 continue to apply regardless of which exemption an issuer chooses.
The only path off registration entirely is a separate safe harbor, proposed as new Rule 400, under which a covered investment contract stops being an investment contract once the issuer has completed or permanently abandoned the managerial efforts it promised investors. That determination rests on the issuer’s own certification on a Form TR filing, not on a Commission finding, and Commission staff has reserved the right to challenge the certification after the fact. The proposal builds on SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293 (1946), and on the transaction by transaction reasoning of SEC v. Ripple Labs, Inc., 682 F. Supp. 3d 308 (S.D.N.Y. 2023), while leaving secondary market registration for exchanges, brokers, and dealers unaddressed. Congress is negotiating a separate and overlapping structure in the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act, still pending in the Senate as of September 2026.
Detailed Findings
What Regulation Crypto Assets actually changes
Regulation Crypto Assets is a proposed new part of the Commission’s rules, 17 CFR Part 228, published for comment together with amendments to 17 CFR Parts 200, 201, 230, 232, and 239. The proposal does not touch the statutory definition of a security in Section 2(a)(1) of the Securities Act of 1933, 15 U.S.C. section 77b(a)(1), and it does not touch Section 5’s requirement that a security be registered before it is offered or sold, 15 U.S.C. section 77e. What the proposal does is create a defined category, the covered investment contract, and then build two conditional exemptions from Section 5 around that category. In thirty years of counseling technology companies through early stage financings, the recurring drafting problem for a token sale has never been finding an exemption from registration. Regulation D and Regulation A already supplied that. The problem has been that no exemption ever addressed whether the token itself stopped being a security once the network it represented actually started working, which is the specific gap Regulation Crypto Assets is the first Commission rule to try to close.
The proposal states plainly that a covered investment contract, once sold under either exemption, remains subject to the antifraud provision of Section 17(a) of the Securities Act, 15 U.S.C. section 77q(a), and to Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Rule 10b-5, 15 U.S.C. section 78j(b) and 17 CFR 240.10b-5. A founder reading only the press release could reasonably conclude that a compliant token sale exits federal securities law. It does not. It exits the registration and prospectus delivery requirements of Section 5 for as long as the issuer stays inside the exemption’s conditions.
The Startup Exemption caps the raise, not the disclosure risk
Proposed Rule 200 permits an issuer to sell covered investment contracts for total consideration of up to 5 million dollars measured over a rolling period of four years, and the covered transactions include airdrops and network rewards distributed with no separate cash sale at all. There is no requirement that purchasers be accredited, no restriction on general solicitation, and the tokens carry no restricted securities label once sold, a marked departure from Regulation D. In exchange for that breadth, the issuer must file a short Form NOR notice before the offering begins, maintain narrative disclosures on a public website covering the ten topics listed in proposed Rule 103, and update those disclosures within 30 days of any material change.
The ten Rule 103 topics cover the terms of the covered investment contract itself, the offering, the issuer’s management and any conflicts of interest, plans for developing the associated network or application, the security of the underlying source code, the allocation and economics of the token supply, how token holders control protocol decisions, the state of the surrounding network and its participants, and a statement of risk factors. Every one of those ten disclosures becomes a statement that Section 17(a) and Rule 10b-5 can be tested against if it later proves false or misleading, so the exemption trades a registration statement for a public disclosure record that carries the same antifraud exposure a prospectus would.
The Fundraising Exemption trades a higher cap for Regulation A style reporting
Proposed Rules 300 through 307 create a two tier Fundraising Exemption modeled on Regulation A. Tier 1 permits up to 20 million dollars in a twelve month period without audited financial statements. Tier 2 permits up to 75 million dollars in a twelve month period but requires audited financial statements and ongoing periodic reporting under proposed Rule 305, including a transition report on Form TR if the issuer later claims the separate investment contract safe harbor. Both tiers require the issuer to be organized in the United States, to keep a majority of its officers and assets in the United States, and to file a detailed offering circular on new Form 1-CRYPTO before selling. Purchasers who are not accredited investors are capped at 10 percent of the greater of their annual income or net worth, the same investor protection ceiling Regulation Crowdfunding uses under 17 CFR 227.100.
An initial reading of the Federal Register release text suggested a 25 million dollar Tier 1 ceiling, but two independent law firm summaries of the same release both describe a 20 million dollar Tier 1 ceiling. That discrepancy has not been resolved against the underlying rule text as of this report and appears as the first item under Open Questions below. Either figure still leaves a meaningful gap below the 75 million dollar Tier 2 ceiling, and either figure still requires the issuer to remain current on its periodic reports for the exemption to keep functioning, a continuing compliance burden that a one time Regulation D placement does not carry.
Rule 400 is the only route to shedding security status, and it is self certified
Proposed Rule 400 is the provision that actually answers whether a token can stop being a security. It states that a covered investment contract is deemed to have ceased to exist as an investment contract once the issuer has completed, or has permanently and irrevocably ceased, the essential managerial efforts it described to purchasers under Rule 103, and once the issuer has filed a Form TR transition report certifying that fact along with supporting analysis. Once that filing is made and the conditions are met, the token itself, as opposed to the original sale transaction, is treated as outside the definition of an investment contract going forward.
The mechanism is unusual for securities law because the trigger is the issuer’s own certification. No Commission order, no no action letter, and no court judgment is required before the token is treated as having exited investment contract status. The proposal reserves the Commission’s authority to bring an enforcement action later if it concludes the certification was inaccurate when filed, which means an issuer that files a Form TR and continues distributing tokens on the assumption that the safe harbor applies is making a bet the Commission can still call years afterward. The proposal also does not set a numeric or technical threshold for what counts as sufficient decentralization or completed managerial effort, leaving that determination to the same fact intensive, multi factor analysis the Commission and the courts have already applied under Howey since 1946.
Howey, Ripple, and Telegram already drew this line, and the proposal follows it
The controlling test for whether a token sale is an investment contract remains the four part test from SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293 (1946): an investment of money, in a common enterprise, with a reasonable expectation of profits, derived from the entrepreneurial or managerial efforts of others. Regulation Crypto Assets does not amend that test. It builds an exemption process around the third and fourth prongs, betting that once managerial effort ends, the reasonable expectation of profit from someone else’s work ends with it.
Two federal district court decisions already tested that same distinction on real facts. In SEC v. Telegram Grp. Inc., 448 F. Supp. 3d 352 (S.D.N.Y. 2020), the court enjoined the distribution of Telegram’s Gram tokens because the initial sale to purchasers who expected Telegram’s engineering team to build and launch a functioning blockchain satisfied Howey, regardless of what the tokens might have looked like once that network matured. In SEC v. Ripple Labs, Inc., 682 F. Supp. 3d 308 (S.D.N.Y. 2023), the court split its analysis by transaction type: institutional sales made under written contracts to sophisticated buyers who knew they were funding Ripple’s efforts satisfied Howey, while programmatic sales executed anonymously through exchange algorithms did not, because those buyers had no reason to know they were buying from Ripple or relying on Ripple’s continued work. Rule 400’s certification requirement is the Commission’s attempt to convert that judicially discovered distinction into a filing an issuer can make prospectively instead of litigating years after the fact.
What the proposal leaves for Congress and for later rulemaking
Regulation Crypto Assets addresses only the primary offer and sale of a covered investment contract by the issuer. It does not address whether a trading platform that lists tokens after the exemption period must register as a national securities exchange under Section 6 of the Exchange Act, 15 U.S.C. section 78f, or whether market makers and wallet providers that facilitate secondary trading must register as brokers or dealers under Section 15, 15 U.S.C. section 78o. Those questions sit with a separate legislative effort, the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act, H.R. 3633, 119th Cong. (2025), which the House passed on July 17, 2025, by a vote of 294 to 134 and which the Senate Banking Committee advanced on May 14, 2026, by a vote of 15 to 9. As of September 2026 the bill remains on the Senate floor calendar, with a cloture motion filed August 8, 2026, and has not received a final Senate vote.
The Clarity Act would assign digital assets on what it calls a mature blockchain to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission as digital commodities, while leaving investment contracts and early stage tokens with the Commission. Regulation Crypto Assets and the Clarity Act cover overlapping ground from different directions, one through Commission rulemaking under existing statutory authority and the other through new legislation that would reassign jurisdiction outright, and a startup planning a token sale in the fourth quarter of 2026 has to track both tracks at once.
Want more industry insights? I publish daily analysis on the intersection of deep tech and venture law.
Open Questions
Does the final Tier 1 cap land at 20 million dollars or 25 million dollars?
Two independent secondary summaries of the Federal Register release describe a 20 million dollar Tier 1 ceiling under the Fundraising Exemption, while an initial review of the release text suggested 25 million dollars. A founder sizing a raise against the wrong figure could structure an offering that exceeds the actual cap, converting an exempt sale into an unregistered one.
What decentralization showing will satisfy Rule 400 in practice?
The proposal sets no numeric threshold, node count, token distribution percentage, or token holder voting requirement for when managerial effort has ended. Until the Commission issues guidance or takes an enforcement position on a real Form TR filing, issuers filing that certification are relying on their own reading of a standard the Commission has not yet applied to a single case.
Will the Commission finalize the rule before, or in tandem with, the Clarity Act?
If Congress passes the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act and reassigns jurisdiction over mature digital commodities to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Regulation Crypto Assets may need to be reconciled with, or withdrawn in favor of, whatever transition mechanism the statute creates. A startup relying on the safe harbor could find its regulator changing mid stream.
Does staying current on Tier 2 periodic reports carry the same liability exposure as Exchange Act reporting?
Proposed Rule 305 requires ongoing reports for Tier 2 issuers but the proposal does not specify whether a materially false statement in one of those reports exposes the issuer to the same private right of action available against Exchange Act filers under Section 18, 15 U.S.C. section 78r, or only to Commission enforcement under Section 17(a).
What happens to tokens sold under the Startup Exemption if the issuer never files a Form TR?
The proposal describes the Startup Exemption as relief that operates while an issuer works toward the safe harbor, but it does not state what obligations, if any, survive at the four year mark for an issuer that neither qualifies for Rule 400 nor moves into a registered offering.
Interested in analysis about the intersection of tech, policy and the law? Check out my Substack channel. https://theinnovationattorney.substack.com/