Biometric Data Laws Update

Biometric Data and Surveillance Regulation

Executive Summary

The Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act has long stood as the nation’s most aggressive biometric privacy statute, generating billions of dollars in litigation and forcing employers to rethink how they collect and use fingerprint and facial geometry data. That position is now being tested from two directions simultaneously. On April 1, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit settled a question that had divided federal district courts: the August 2024 amendment to BIPA, which changed the damages calculation from a per-scan basis to a per-person basis, applies retroactively to all cases pending at the time of enactment. That ruling, issued in Clay v. Union Pacific Railroad, collapsed potential nine-figure exposure into five-figure caps for thousands of plaintiffs.

At the same time, legislatures far beyond Illinois are accelerating. Alabama passed HB 351 on April 7, 2026, classifying biometric data and facial recognition templates as sensitive personal data requiring explicit opt-in consent. Virginia’s revised facial recognition statute takes effect July 1, 2026, imposing warrant requirements, mandatory audit trails, and annual public reporting on every law enforcement agency that uses the technology. Colorado’s biometric privacy amendment to the Colorado Privacy Act became effective July 1, 2025. Texas secured a $1.4 billion settlement from Meta in July 2024 under the state’s Capture or Use of Biometric Identifier Act, the largest biometric enforcement action ever brought by a single state. At the federal level, the ICE Out of Our Faces Act, introduced in February 2026, would prohibit Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Customs and Border Protection from deploying facial recognition entirely.

The combined effect is a patchwork of state regimes with divergent consent standards, enforcement mechanisms, and damages structures. The question facing every technology company that touches biometric data is no longer whether to comply with BIPA alone. It is how to build a compliance program that works across twenty-one states with materially different rules.

Detailed Findings

The Seventh Circuit’s Retroactivity Ruling in Clay v. Union Pacific Railroad

On April 1, 2026, a unanimous three-judge panel of the Seventh Circuit issued its opinion in Clay v. Union Pacific Railroad Company, No. 25-2185 (7th Cir. 2026). The court consolidated three interlocutory appeals from federal district courts that had reached conflicting conclusions on a single question: whether the August 2024 amendment to the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act applied to cases that were already filed and pending when the amendment became law.

The 2024 amendment, enacted in response to a wave of class action litigation that threatened employers with exposure exceeding $5,000 per biometric scan per employee, provides that an entity that obtains the same biometric identifier or biometric information from the same person using the same method of collection in violation of BIPA’s notice and consent requirements has committed a single violation of the act. Before the amendment, courts read BIPA’s liquidated damages provision to generate a separate cause of action for each individual scan, meaning a single employee who clocked in and out with a fingerprint scanner 1,500 times over several years could claim up to $7.5 million in statutory damages for willful violations under the pre-amendment calculation. The amendment collapses that figure to a single per-person recovery: $5,000 for willful violations and $1,000 for negligent violations.

The Seventh Circuit held that the amendment is remedial rather than substantive because it modifies the liquidated damages section of the statute without altering the underlying duty or the elements of a cause of action. Under established principles of retroactivity in Illinois law, remedial amendments that affect only the remedy for a right already vested apply to pending cases. The court reversed three lower court decisions that had held the amendment prospective only. For defendants with mass biometric data practices already in litigation, the ruling effectively eliminates exposure that in some cases had been calculated in the hundreds of millions of dollars.

Alabama: HB 351 and the Twenty-First State Privacy Law

Alabama’s legislature passed HB 351 on April 7, 2026, making Alabama the twenty-first state to enact a comprehensive consumer data privacy statute. The bill was introduced by Representative Shaw and modeled in significant part on the Virginia Consumer Data Protection Act and the Colorado Privacy Act.

Under HB 351, biometric data and facial recognition templates are classified as sensitive personal data. That classification triggers the statute’s most restrictive requirement: controllers may not process sensitive data without first obtaining the consumer’s explicit affirmative consent. This opt-in requirement represents a more protective standard than the opt-out framework that governs most other categories of personal data under the bill.

The coverage threshold is set at controllers that process personal data of 25,000 or more Alabama consumers or that derive 25 percent or more of gross revenue from the sale of personal data. Enforcement is reserved to the Alabama Attorney General exclusively. There is no private right of action. The law includes a 45-day cure period before the Attorney General may bring an action, consistent with other state privacy statutes in the Southern tier. If signed by the governor, the law takes effect May 1, 2027.

The absence of a private right of action distinguishes Alabama sharply from Illinois. Plaintiffs’ firms that have driven BIPA litigation cannot replicate that model in Alabama. The practical consequence is that enforcement in Alabama will depend entirely on prosecutorial priorities within the Attorney General’s office, a pattern that has produced spotty results in other AG-only enforcement states.

Virginia: Facial Recognition and Law Enforcement Constraints

Virginia’s revised facial recognition statute, codified at Virginia Code Section 15.2-1723.2, takes effect July 1, 2026. The law imposes three categories of obligations on every local law enforcement agency that uses facial recognition technology.

First, the statute addresses probable cause. A match produced by facial recognition technology may not be included in an affidavit to establish probable cause for a search warrant or an arrest warrant. The match is, however, admissible as exculpatory evidence. This asymmetric treatment reflects a legislative judgment that facial recognition match rates carry insufficient reliability to justify deprivation of liberty but are reliable enough to exonerate. The practical consequence is that law enforcement agencies in Virginia may use facial recognition as an investigative lead generator but must develop independent corroborating evidence before seeking judicial process.

Second, the statute imposes detailed audit and recordkeeping obligations. Each agency must maintain records sufficient to support discovery in criminal and post-conviction proceedings, must track a complete history of each user’s queries, must record the number of queries that resulted in investigative leads and the number that contributed to case closures, and must document demographic information for every individual whose image was queried. Those records must be available for public reporting and compliance auditing.

Third, each chief of police whose agency uses facial recognition must publicly post and annually update by April 1 of each year a report providing the public with information about the agency’s use of the technology. These annual reporting obligations create a public transparency mechanism that enables civil society organizations and journalists to monitor deployment patterns and identify potential disparities in how the technology is applied across communities.

Texas: The CUBI Framework and the Meta Settlement

Texas enacted the Capture or Use of Biometric Identifier Act in 2009, making it the second state after Illinois to regulate biometric data collection. Texas Business and Commerce Code Chapter 503 requires any person who captures a biometric identifier of an individual for a commercial purpose to inform the individual before or at the time of the capture, to inform the individual of the specific purpose and length of time for which the biometric identifier is to be captured, stored, or used, and to receive the individual’s consent.

Unlike BIPA, CUBI provides no private right of action. Enforcement authority rests exclusively with the Texas Attorney General, who may seek civil penalties of up to $25,000 per violation. The AG-only model produced almost no enforcement activity for fifteen years. That changed in February 2022, when then-Attorney General Ken Paxton filed suit against Meta Platforms alleging that Meta had captured and stored facial geometry data from photographs uploaded by Texas users through its Tag Suggestions feature without obtaining the required consent. On July 30, 2024, Meta agreed to pay $1.4 billion over five years to settle the action. The settlement is the largest ever obtained by a single state attorney general in any privacy enforcement action and dwarfs the $390 million multi-state settlement with Google reached in late 2022.

The Texas Responsible Artificial Intelligence Act, signed June 22, 2025, and effective January 1, 2026, amended CUBI to address a question that practitioners had flagged since the Meta filing: whether biometric data collected by security systems or used to train artificial intelligence models falls within CUBI’s commercial purpose requirement. The amendment creates a limited exemption for safety, security, and law enforcement applications tied to AI systems as defined by the statute. The amendment also clarifies that disclosure of biometric identifiers to law enforcement agencies acting pursuant to a warrant is permissible.

Washington: A Biometric Law Without Enforcement History

Washington enacted its biometric privacy statute as Revised Code of Washington Chapter 19.375 in 2017, becoming the third state after Illinois and Texas to regulate biometric identifiers. Like Texas, Washington’s law is enforced exclusively by the attorney general under the consumer protection act. Also like Texas, Washington’s law excludes photographs, video recordings, and audio recordings from the definition of biometric identifier, a carve-out that substantially limits the statute’s reach in facial recognition contexts.

As of April 2026, the Washington Attorney General has brought no enforcement actions under RCW 19.375. The absence of any enforcement history is notable given the scale of biometric data processing by major technology companies headquartered in Washington and operating throughout the state. Washington does maintain a separate statutory framework governing government agency use of facial recognition technology, enacted as RCW Chapter 43.386, which imposes additional constraints on state and local government entities.

Colorado: Employer Obligations Under the Biometric Privacy Amendment

Colorado amended its Privacy Act through HB 24-1130, which took effect July 1, 2025. The Biometric Amendment extends the Colorado Privacy Act’s coverage to any controller that processes biometric identifiers collected from Colorado residents, regardless of whether the controller otherwise meets the CPA’s general jurisdictional thresholds. That universal applicability is significant: even a small business that uses a fingerprint time-clock system but processes no other personal data subject to the CPA must comply with the biometric provisions.

Controllers subject to the Biometric Amendment must adopt a written biometric policy establishing a retention schedule, require informed written consent from consumers prior to collecting biometric identifiers, and delete biometric data when the original collection purpose has been fulfilled or within 24 months of the last interaction with the individual, whichever comes first.

For employers specifically, the Biometric Amendment permits requiring employee consent to biometric collection as a condition of employment in four limited circumstances: access to secure physical locations, hardware, or software applications; recording the beginning and end of a full workday; improving or monitoring workplace safety or security; and monitoring public safety during emergencies or crises. Location tracking and monitoring time spent using software applications are explicitly excluded from the permissible condition-of-employment exceptions.

Colorado enforcement is shared between the Attorney General and district attorneys. Violations constitute deceptive trade practices under the Colorado Consumer Protection Act, subject to civil penalties of up to $20,000 per violation. There is no private right of action.

New York City: The Commercial Establishment Biometric Ordinance

New York City’s Biometric Identifier Information Law, codified at Chapter 12 of Title 22 of the New York City Administrative Code, imposes obligations on commercial establishments defined as places of entertainment, retail stores, and food and drink establishments that collect, retain, convert, store, or share biometric identifier information from customers.

The ordinance requires covered establishments to post a clear and conspicuous sign at all customer entrances notifying customers in plain language that biometric identifier information is being collected, retained, converted, stored, or shared. Critically, the ordinance prohibits commercial establishments from selling, leasing, trading, sharing in exchange for anything of value, or otherwise profiting from biometric identifier data.

Unlike most state biometric frameworks, the New York City ordinance provides a private right of action. Individuals who believe a covered establishment has failed to post required signage must provide the establishment with 30 days’ written notice before filing suit. If the establishment remedies the failure within that period, no action may be maintained for the signage violation. No cure period applies to the prohibition on profiting from biometric data: a plaintiff may sue immediately for any violation of the sale and profit ban. Statutory damages range from $500 to $5,000 per violation depending on whether the violation was negligent or intentional, and prevailing plaintiffs are entitled to attorneys’ fees.

At the state level, proposed legislation designated S1422 in the New York Senate and A6031 in the Assembly would create a comprehensive statewide Biometric Privacy Act modeled on BIPA, including a private right of action. As of April 2026, neither bill had advanced out of committee.

Federal Landscape: The ICE Out of Our Faces Act

Senator Edward Markey of Massachusetts, joined by Senators Jeff Merkley and Ron Wyden of Oregon and Representative Pramila Jayapal of Washington, introduced the ICE Out of Our Faces Act on February 5, 2026, as S. 3779 of the 119th Congress. The bill would prohibit Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Customs and Border Protection from acquiring or using facial recognition technology or other biometric identification systems.

The bill would further require the deletion of all data already collected for use in or by biometric identification systems operated by ICE and CBP, and would grant individuals and state attorneys general the right to seek civil penalties for violations. Co-sponsors include Senators Angela Alsobrooks of Maryland and Bernie Sanders of Vermont.

The bill’s introduction coincided with public reporting on expanded use by ICE of mobile facial recognition tools to profile and identify individuals in the field. Supporting organizations include the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the Electronic Privacy Information Center, the American Civil Liberties Union, Fight for the Future, and Human Rights First.

The bill has not been scheduled for a hearing or a vote in either chamber. Given the current composition of Congress, its prospects for enactment in the 119th Congress are limited. The bill functions primarily as a statement of legislative intent and a marker for future federal biometric regulation if political conditions change.

Open Questions

First, the Seventh Circuit’s retroactivity ruling in Clay v. Union Pacific Railroad resolves the damages question for pending BIPA cases but does not address whether the Illinois Supreme Court’s future interpretation of “single violation” will align with the Seventh Circuit’s reading or produce a narrower or broader definition. The Illinois Supreme Court has not yet construed the amended statute, and any divergence between state court and federal court interpretation could re-open damages disputes in state court filings.

Second, it remains unclear whether states following the Alabama model of sensitive data with explicit consent requirements, but with AG-only enforcement and cure periods, will generate meaningful deterrence without a private right of action. The BIPA litigation wave was entirely plaintiff-driven. Attorney general offices in Alabama, Colorado, and Washington have finite resources and competing enforcement priorities. The practical deterrence question is whether AG-only enforcement will produce compliance rates sufficient to protect consumers or whether it will remain largely aspirational.

Third, Virginia’s facial recognition warrant restriction does not address the use of facial recognition evidence in civil proceedings, administrative hearings, or immigration proceedings. Agencies operating at the federal level within Virginia are not bound by the state statute’s constraints. The interaction between Virginia’s state-law evidentiary restrictions and federal agency practice in the same geographic area has not been litigated.

Fourth, the Texas Responsible AI Act’s security exemption to CUBI raises questions about the scope of the exemption: specifically, whether private employers may claim a security purpose justification to avoid consent requirements for employee-facing biometric systems, or whether the exemption applies only to AI-driven security systems as narrowly defined in the statute.

Fifth, proposed federal legislation such as the ICE Out of Our Faces Act has failed repeatedly, but the underlying technology deployment by federal agencies is accelerating. An unresolved constitutional question is whether the Fourth Amendment’s prohibition on unreasonable searches and seizures imposes any limits on federal agency use of facial recognition in public spaces, particularly as applied to individuals who have not been stopped or detained.

Bibliography

Clay v. Union Pacific Railroad Company, No. 25-2185 (7th Cir. Apr. 1, 2026). Available at Justia, https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca7/25-2185/25-2185-2026-04-01.html.

Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act, 740 Ill. Comp. Stat. 14/1 et seq. (2008), as amended by Public Act 103-769 (Aug. 2024).

Alabama HB 351, 2026 Regular Session (passed Apr. 7, 2026). Available at Alabama Legislature, https://alison.legislature.state.al.us.

Virginia Code Section 15.2-1723.2 (effective July 1, 2026). Available at Virginia Law, https://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/title15.2/chapter17/section15.2-1723.2/.

Texas Business and Commerce Code Chapter 503. Available at Texas Legislature Online, https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/BC/htm/BC.503.htm.

Texas HB 149 (Texas Responsible Artificial Intelligence Governance Act), 89th Legislature (signed Jun. 22, 2025, effective Jan. 1, 2026).

Colorado HB 24-1130, Privacy of Biometric Identifiers and Data. Available at Colorado General Assembly, https://leg.colorado.gov/bills/hb24-1130.

Washington Revised Code Chapter 19.375. Available at Washington State Legislature, https://app.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=19.375.

New York City Administrative Code, Chapter 12 of Title 22 (Biometric Identifier Information). Available at NYC Administrative Code.

S. 3779, 119th Congress (2025-2026), ICE Out of Our Faces Act (introduced Feb. 5, 2026). Available at Congress.gov, https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/senate-bill/3779/text.

Inside Privacy (Covington). “Seventh Circuit Holds that BIPA Amendment Applies Retroactively.” April 2026. https://www.insideprivacy.com/data-privacy/seventh-circuit-holds-that-bipa-amendment-applies-retroactively/.

Sidley Austin Data Matters. “Seventh Circuit Limits Potential Damages Under BIPA, Holds 2024 Amendment Applies Retroactively.” April 8, 2026. https://datamatters.sidley.com/2026/04/08/seventh-circuit-limits-potential-damages-under-bipa-holds-2024-amendment-applies-retroactively/.

Texas Attorney General. “Attorney General Ken Paxton Secures $1.4 Billion Settlement with Meta Over Its Unauthorized Capture of Personal Biometric Data.” July 30, 2024. https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/attorney-general-ken-paxton-secures-14-billion-settlement-meta-over-its-unauthorized-capture.

Security Industry Association. “Groundbreaking Texas AI Law Also Brings Needed Clarity on Use of Biometric Technologies for Security.” June 24, 2025. https://www.securityindustry.org/2025/06/24/groundbreaking-texas-ai-law-also-brings-needed-clarity-on-use-of-biometric-technologies-for-security/.

Davis Wright Tremaine. “New Requirements on the Collection and Use of Biometrics in Colorado Become Effective Soon.” May 2025. https://www.dwt.com/blogs/privacy–security-law-blog/2025/05/colorado-privacy-act-biometrics-updates-july-2025/.

Electronic Frontier Foundation. “Yes to the ICE Out of Our Faces Act.” February 2026. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2026/02/yes-ice-out-my-face-act.

Paul Hastings. “7th Circuit Confirms BIPA Amendment Has Retroactive Application.” April 2026. https://www.paulhastings.com/insights/ph-privacy/7th-circuit-confirms-bipa-amendment-has-retroactive-application.

GovPing / Changeflow. “Alabama Enacts 21st State Privacy Law, HB 351.” April 10, 2026. https://changeflow.com/govping/data-privacy-cybersecurity/alabama-passes-privacy-law-becomes-21st-state-2026-04-10.

Interested in analysis about the intersection of tech, policy and the law? Check out my Substack channel. https://theinnovationattorney.substack.com/