AI Washing Securities Fraud: The Joonko founder’s $27 million Guilty Plea
Executive Summary
Joonko founder Ilit Raz pleaded guilty on September 11, 2026 in the Southern District of New York to a $27 million securities fraud built on fabricated customer records. The plea follows a civil complaint the SEC filed against Raz in June 2024 alleging at least $21 million in investor losses, SEC v. Ilit Raz, No. 24 civ 4466 (S.D.N.Y.), and it is the newest entry in a sequence running from the SEC’s March 2024 orders against Delphia and Global Predictions through the 2025 prosecution of former Nate Inc. chief executive Albert Saniger and the 20 year sentence imposed on Ramil Palafox of PGI Global in February 2026, a sequence that treats a founder’s description of an artificial intelligence product as a securities disclosure.
The legal theory is not new. Section 17(a) of the Securities Act of 1933, Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, and Rule 10b-5 already reach a misstatement about what a product does, whether the product is an artificial intelligence model or a spreadsheet. What is newly settled is prosecutorial appetite: the Department of Justice brought parallel criminal charges in the Saniger and Raz matters, and the FTC has pursued a separate Section 5 track against business to business AI vendors. Still being tested is how far this theory reaches into seed rounds raised under Regulation D, where no SEC form review occurs before the money changes hands.
For founders and counsel who paper a priced round, every claim about model performance, customer count, and revenue in a deck carries the same exposure as a line in a public annual report. This report examines the Joonko prosecution, the enforcement record surrounding it, director and officer exposure under a knew or should have known standard, and the verification steps a board should complete before signing a term sheet.
Detailed Findings
The Joonko prosecution: from civil complaint to guilty plea
Joonko Diversity, Inc. marketed an artificial intelligence recruiting platform and raised two priced rounds on that pitch: a $10 million Series A on approximately June 1, 2021 and a $17 million Series B on approximately June 2, 2022, for a combined $27 million (United States Attorney’s Office, S.D.N.Y., press release, Sept. 11, 2026). The SEC’s civil complaint, filed June 11, 2024, alleges Raz told investors Joonko had more than 100 customers including Fortune 500 companies, supplied fabricated customer testimonials, represented revenue above $1 million, and claimed more than 100,000 active candidates used the platform (SEC v. Ilit Raz, No. 24 civ 4466 (S.D.N.Y.)).
When an investor confronted Raz in mid 2023 about the gap between the pitch and the business, she produced a forged bank statement showing a balance above $5 million when the company’s actual balance was several million dollars lower, and in April 2023 she circulated forged purchase orders carrying fabricated counterparty signatures from companies that had never signed anything with Joonko (United States Attorney’s Office, S.D.N.Y., press release, Sept. 11, 2026). Raz eventually admitted to the investor that she had forged the documents, which is the admission that opened both the SEC’s civil case and the criminal referral that followed it (fhnylaw.com, Enforcement News: SEC Charges Founder of Joonko).
Raz entered her guilty plea on September 11, 2026 before U.S. District Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, prosecuted by the Securities and Commodities Fraud Task Force of the United States Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York, and faces a maximum of 20 years in prison (United States Attorney’s Office, S.D.N.Y., press release, Sept. 11, 2026). The SEC’s parallel civil case still seeks a permanent injunction, civil monetary penalties, disgorgement with prejudgment interest, and an officer and director bar against Raz (SEC Litigation Release No. 26020). SEC Enforcement Director Gurbir S. Grewal described the conduct as an old school fraud using new school buzzwords, a line that frames the finding running through every case in this report: the artificial intelligence label attached to a product does not change the antifraud analysis applied to the claims made about it (fhnylaw.com, Enforcement News: SEC Charges Founder of Joonko).
The SEC’s AI washing program: Delphia, Global Predictions, and Presto Automation
In March 2024 the SEC brought its first artificial intelligence washing cases, against registered investment advisers Delphia (USA) Inc. and Global Predictions Inc. (Debevoise & Plimpton, AI Enforcement Starts with Washing, Mar. 2024). Delphia was charged under Section 206(2) of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, the Compliance Rule under Rule 206(4)-7, and the Marketing Rule under Rule 206(4)-1, for claiming it used a predictive algorithmic model that analyzed client shared data to forecast consumer and economic trends. The SEC found no such model existed and that Delphia repeated the claim for nearly two years after its own examiners had flagged the misstatement (Debevoise & Plimpton, AI Enforcement Starts with Washing, Mar. 2024).
Global Predictions, charged under the same antifraud and compliance provisions, advertised expert artificial intelligence driven forecasts and described itself as the first regulated artificial intelligence financial advisor across its website, client communications, and social media, none of which the underlying technology supported (Debevoise & Plimpton, AI Enforcement Starts with Washing, Mar. 2024). In January 2025 Presto Automation settled SEC charges that it told investors its restaurant drive through product was fully automated while a third party actually owned the technology and human staff completed a material share of orders; the SEC treated the conduct as negligence based rather than intentional and imposed no penalty or disgorgement (White & Case, Evolution of AI Washing Enforcement, 2026).
Former SEC Chair Gary Gensler’s statement that the antifraud provisions already written into the securities laws apply with equal force to an artificial intelligence claim as to any other claim is the premise every later action in this sequence builds on (Debevoise & Plimpton, AI Enforcement Starts with Washing, Mar. 2024).
DOJ’s criminal AI washing theories: Saniger and Palafox
In April 2025 the Department of Justice indicted Albert Saniger, former chief executive of Nate, Inc., on securities fraud and wire fraud, each carrying a maximum of 20 years in prison, for telling investors that the Nate shopping application completed 93 to 97 percent of purchases through proprietary artificial intelligence (United States Attorney’s Office, S.D.N.Y., press release, Tech CEO Charged With Artificial Intelligence Investment Fraud Scheme, Apr. 2025). The actual automation rate approached zero. Hundreds of contract workers in the Philippines manually completed the transactions Nate’s marketing credited to its model, Saniger restricted internal access to the metrics that would have exposed the gap, and he later directed engineers to build software whose purpose was to manufacture the appearance of automation for investors (United States Attorney’s Office, S.D.N.Y., press release, Apr. 2025). Nate raised more than $40 million on the claim (The D&O Diary, Tech Exec Charged with AI Washing Related Securities Fraud, Apr. 2025).
Acting United States Attorney Podolsky stated that Saniger misled investors by exploiting the promise and allure of artificial intelligence technology to build a false narrative about innovation that never existed, and FBI Assistant Director Raia stated that Saniger defrauded investors with fabrications of his company’s purported artificial intelligence capabilities while covertly employing personnel to satisfy the illusion (United States Attorney’s Office, S.D.N.Y., press release, Apr. 2025).
The SEC separately charged Ramil Palafox, founder of PGI Global, with raising approximately $198 million from investors worldwide on claims of a proprietary automated trading platform for crypto assets and foreign exchange that used artificial intelligence (SEC press release 2025 69). No legitimate trading occurred. Palafox diverted more than $57 million to personal purchases including vehicles, watches, and real estate, and used new investor funds to pay earlier investors until the scheme collapsed in late 2021 (SEC press release 2025 69). Palafox was sentenced to 20 years in prison in February 2026 and ordered to pay more than $46.8 million in restitution (BehindMLM, PGI Global’s RV Palafox Sentenced to 20 Years, 2026).
Saniger and Palafox establish that the Department of Justice will charge an artificial intelligence capability claim as the predicate misstatement in a securities fraud indictment whether the victims are venture investors in a priced round or retail investors in an unregistered trading product, and the Raz plea in September 2026 confirms the same theory reaches a venture financing with named, identifiable Series A and Series B investors (SEC v. Ilit Raz, No. 24 civ 4466 (S.D.N.Y.); United States Attorney’s Office, S.D.N.Y., press release, Sept. 11, 2026).
The FTC’s parallel Section 5 track
Separate from the securities law theories available to the SEC and DOJ, the Federal Trade Commission enforces Section 5 of the FTC Act against deceptive artificial intelligence marketing claims aimed at business customers as well as consumers. A 2026 settlement with CMG Media Corporation and two marketing vendors addressed claims that an Active Listening advertising tool captured smart device voice data with consumer consent for geographic ad targeting, when the companies had in fact purchased and resold conventional data broker email lists; the three companies paid a combined $930,000 in consumer redress (DLA Piper, FTC AI Washing Action Underscores Enforcement in Business to Business Context, May 2026).
The DLA Piper review counted the CMG matter as the seventh of the FTC’s last eight artificial intelligence washing settlements involving business to business marketing claims, which means a startup selling an artificial intelligence enabled product to other companies, not only one raising capital from investors, carries exposure under a second federal enforcement track with its own notion of a material misrepresentation (DLA Piper, FTC AI Washing Action Underscores Enforcement in Business to Business Context, May 2026).
Investor class actions and private securities litigation
Civil exposure extends beyond SEC and DOJ action. Board oversight commentary citing current litigation data reports that private shareholder class actions alleging artificial intelligence misrepresentation doubled year over year (J.S. Held, AI Washing and the Imperative for Board Governance, 2026). The private financing context changes an investor’s path to relief but not the underlying violation: Section 17(a) and Rule 10b-5 apply to the offer and sale of securities whether the issuer is public or private, and a Regulation D exemption removes the registration requirement without removing antifraud liability (Berkeley Technology Law Journal, Was the AI in the Code? Or Just in the Valuation?, Apr. 2026).
The gap identified in the Berkeley Technology Law Journal’s review of the Saniger matter is procedural rather than substantive: a private placement memorandum or data room is not subject to routine SEC review before the money moves, so the first external check on an artificial intelligence claim in a priced round is frequently the diligence a lead investor chooses to perform rather than a regulator (Berkeley Technology Law Journal, Was the AI in the Code? Or Just in the Valuation?, Apr. 2026).
Director and officer liability exposure
The SEC’s request for an officer and director bar against Raz places board service itself inside the remedy a court can impose, not only the company’s balance sheet (SEC Litigation Release No. 26020). Commentary addressed to corporate boards frames the exposure for outside directors in terms of what the director knew or should have known about the gap between the claimed artificial intelligence capability and the product the engineering team actually shipped (J.S. Held, AI Washing and the Imperative for Board Governance, 2026).
A startup’s directors and officers liability policy ordinarily defends a securities claim until a court makes a final adjudication of fraud, after which a fraud exclusion bars further coverage, which means the practical protection a policy affords during an SEC investigation or a shareholder suit turns on facts established well after the policy was bound rather than on the underwriting file. A board member who approved a financing round without independently verifying a material artificial intelligence claim faces the same personal exposure whether the company is private or public, because the officer and director bar the SEC sought against Raz is a securities law remedy tied to the individual, not the entity (SEC Litigation Release No. 26020).
Diligence and board level verification practices for a priced round
Every fact pattern described above would have failed a specific, available check before the money moved. Joonko’s claimed 100 customers and seven figure revenue could have been confirmed by a diligence team that called the named counterparties directly, through contact information the diligence team obtained independently rather than one supplied by the company, rather than relying on the testimonials Raz provided (SEC v. Ilit Raz, No. 24 civ 4466 (S.D.N.Y.)). Nate’s claimed 93 to 97 percent automation could have been tested by asking the engineering team for access to inference logs and cloud infrastructure billing, since a product running overwhelmingly on human labor in a Philippine call center carries a cost structure that a model running on inference calls does not, and a line item for contract labor in the company’s own expense ledger would have contradicted the automation percentage pitched to investors (United States Attorney’s Office, S.D.N.Y., press release, Apr. 2025). Palafox’s trading platform could have been tested by asking for a third party audit of actual trading activity and account balances rather than accepting dashboard screenshots, the same step that would have caught Raz’s forged bank statement (SEC press release 2025 69; United States Attorney’s Office, S.D.N.Y., press release, Sept. 11, 2026).
The diligence lesson is that an artificial intelligence claim is a factual representation like any other, and it should be verified the way a lead investor already verifies revenue, customer contracts, and bank balances before a priced round closes: bank statements confirmed directly with the issuing institution rather than accepted as a document from the company, customer contracts confirmed by an independent call or email to a counterparty representative whose identity and authority the diligence team checks separately, and revenue figures reconciled against payment processor records the diligence team pulls itself rather than a summary the founder prepares. An artificial intelligence capability claim adds one more item to that list rather than a different category of question: a technical reviewer, whether in house or retained for the round, should ask for the training data, the model architecture, and the infrastructure billing that a genuine artificial intelligence product generates, and should treat a refusal to provide access on the ground that the technology is proprietary the same way a refusal to let an accountant confirm a bank balance would be treated.
At the board level, verification should not end with the diligence memorandum. A board approving a priced round should require the chief executive and chief financial officer to certify in writing, as part of the closing deliverables, that the customer, revenue, and product capability representations made in the data room are complete and accurate, a practice modeled on the officer certifications the Sarbanes Oxley Act requires of public company executives but available to any private board willing to adopt it by resolution. The stock purchase agreement should carry representations and warranties addressed specifically to artificial intelligence product claims, customer counts, and revenue recognition, with indemnification and clawback provisions tied to a breach, so that a misrepresentation discovered after closing carries a contractual remedy in addition to whatever the SEC or DOJ later pursues. Counsel papering the round should treat the deck and data room the way securities counsel treats a prospectus: every factual claim in those materials is a statement made in connection with the offer and sale of a security under Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5, and the same materiality analysis that applies to a public company’s disclosure applies to a Series A deck, whether or not a regulator reads it before the wire transfer clears.
Want more industry insights? I publish daily analysis on the intersection of deep tech and venture law.
Open Questions
Whether the Department of Justice will extend the Saniger and Raz charging theory to seed and pre seed rounds raised under Regulation D with far smaller dollar amounts than the $27 million at issue in Joonko or the $40 million at issue in Nate remains to be tested. The statute sets no dollar floor, and a prosecutor deciding which cases to bring weighs investigator resources and investor harm rather than a legal threshold, so the answer matters to every founder below the headline figures in this report.
Whether a court will test the standard commentary has applied to outside directors, asking what a director knew or should have known about an artificial intelligence misrepresentation, rather than the standard appearing only in secondary sources, will determine how much personal exposure a venture backed company’s independent directors actually carry and how directors and officers insurers price that exposure at the next renewal.
Whether the Securities and Exchange Commission will propose an artificial intelligence specific disclosure rule, rather than continuing to apply Section 17(a), Section 10(b), and the Investment Advisers Act sections already on the books, affects how much certainty a company drafting investor facing artificial intelligence claims can expect, since the current approach leaves the materiality line to be drawn case by case.
Whether the Federal Trade Commission’s business to business artificial intelligence washing track, illustrated by the CMG Media settlement, will reach venture backed artificial intelligence vendors whose customers are other companies rather than consumers matters to every startup whose go to market motion is enterprise sales rather than a consumer product.
Whether private securities class actions against venture backed companies will succeed at the rate the public company artificial intelligence litigation data shows, given that a Regulation D offering reaches no public trading market and no class of secondary purchasers in the sense Rule 10b-5 case law usually addresses, will shape whether a disappointed Series A or Series B investor has a practical path to a jury rather than only a derivative claim against the company itself.
Source List
United States Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York, press release, Founder and Former CEO of Artificial Intelligence Company Pleads Guilty to Securities Fraud (Sept. 11, 2026), https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/founder-and-former-ceo-artificial-intelligence-company-pleads-guilty-securities-fraud. Primary source for the Raz guilty plea, the $27 million figure, the forged documents, and the judge and prosecutors.
Securities and Exchange Commission, Litigation Release No. 26020, SEC v. Ilit Raz, No. 24 civ 4466 (S.D.N.Y. filed June 11, 2024), https://www.sec.gov/enforcement-litigation/litigation-releases/lr-26020. Primary source for the SEC’s civil charges, the $21 million loss figure, and the requested officer and director bar.
United States Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York, press release, Tech CEO Charged With Artificial Intelligence Investment Fraud Scheme (Apr. 2025), https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/tech-ceo-charged-artificial-intelligence-investment-fraud-scheme. Primary source for the Saniger indictment, the Nate automation claim, and the prosecutor and FBI statements.
Securities and Exchange Commission, press release 2025 69, SEC Charges Founder of Crypto Asset and Foreign Exchange Trading Company with $198 Million Fraud Scheme (2025), https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2025-69. Primary source for the Palafox and PGI Global charges and the $198 million figure.
Debevoise & Plimpton, AI Enforcement Starts with Washing: The SEC Charges its First AI Fraud Cases (Mar. 2024), https://www.debevoise.com/insights/publications/2024/03/ai-enforcement-starts-with-washing-the-sec-charges. Source for the first AI washing orders against Delphia and Global Predictions and the Advisers Act sections charged.
White & Case, Evolution of AI Washing Enforcement: DOJ Enters the Picture (2026), https://www.whitecase.com/insight-alert/evolution-ai-washing-enforcement-doj-enters-picture. Source for the Presto Automation settlement and the timeline connecting the SEC’s civil program to DOJ’s criminal charges.
J.S. Held, AI Washing and the Imperative for Board Governance (2026), https://www.jsheld.com/insights/articles/ai-washing-and-the-imperative-for-board-governance. Source for the director liability standard and board verification commentary.
Berkeley Technology Law Journal, Was the AI in the Code? Or Just in the Valuation? AI Washing in Venture Fundraising (Apr. 2026), https://btlj.org/2026/04/was-the-ai-in-the-code-or-just-in-the-valuation-ai-washing-in-venture-fundraising/. Source for the application of Section 17(a) and Rule 10b-5 to private offerings and the Regulation D oversight gap.
DLA Piper, FTC AI Washing Action Underscores Enforcement in Business to Business Context (May 2026), https://www.dlapiper.com/en-us/insights/publications/2026/05/ftc-ai-washing-action-underscores-enforcement-in-business-to-business-context. Source for the CMG Media settlement and the FTC’s Section 5 enforcement pattern.
Fox Horan and Camerini LLP, Enforcement News: SEC Charges Founder of Joonko with Perpetrating an Old School Fraud Using New School Buzzwords, https://fhnylaw.com/enforcement-news-sec-charges-founder-of-joonko-with-perpetrating-an-old-school-fraud-using-new-school-buzzwords/. Source for the detailed allegations in the SEC’s civil complaint and the SEC Enforcement Director’s statement.
The D&O Diary, Tech Exec Charged with AI Washing Related Securities Fraud (Apr. 2025), https://www.dandodiary.com/2025/04/articles/securities-enforcement/tech-exec-charged-with-ai-washing-related-securities-fraud/. Source confirming the Saniger charges and framing the case within director and officer liability commentary.
BehindMLM, PGI Global’s RV Palafox Sentenced to 20 Years (2026), https://behindmlm.com/companies/pgi-global/pgi-globals-rv-palafox-sentenced-to-20-years/. Source for the February 2026 sentencing and restitution figures.
Bibliography
17 C.F.R. section 240.10b 5.
17 C.F.R. section 275.206(4) 1.
17 C.F.R. section 275.206(4) 7.
Federal Trade Commission Act section 5, 15 U.S.C. section 45.
In the Matter of Delphia (USA) Inc., Advisers Act Release (Securities and Exchange Commission, Mar. 2024).
In the Matter of Global Predictions Inc., Advisers Act Release (Securities and Exchange Commission, Mar. 2024).
Investment Advisers Act of 1940 section 206(2), 15 U.S.C. section 80b 6(2).
Press Release, Securities and Exchange Commission, SEC Charges Founder of Crypto Asset and Foreign Exchange Trading Company with $198 Million Fraud Scheme (2025), https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2025-69.
Press Release, United States Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York, Founder and Former CEO of Artificial Intelligence Company Pleads Guilty to Securities Fraud (Sept. 11, 2026), https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/founder-and-former-ceo-artificial-intelligence-company-pleads-guilty-securities-fraud.
Press Release, United States Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York, Tech CEO Charged With Artificial Intelligence Investment Fraud Scheme (Apr. 2025), https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/tech-ceo-charged-artificial-intelligence-investment-fraud-scheme.
SEC v. Ilit Raz, No. 24 civ 4466 (S.D.N.Y. filed June 11, 2024).
Securities Act of 1933 section 17(a), 15 U.S.C. section 77q(a).
Securities Exchange Act of 1934 section 10(b), 15 U.S.C. section 78j(b).
Securities and Exchange Commission, Litigation Release No. 26020 (June 11, 2024), https://www.sec.gov/enforcement-litigation/litigation-releases/lr-26020.
BehindMLM. PGI Global’s RV Palafox Sentenced to 20 Years. 2026. https://behindmlm.com/companies/pgi-global/pgi-globals-rv-palafox-sentenced-to-20-years/.
Berkeley Technology Law Journal. Was the AI in the Code? Or Just in the Valuation? AI Washing in Venture Fundraising. April 2026. https://btlj.org/2026/04/was-the-ai-in-the-code-or-just-in-the-valuation-ai-washing-in-venture-fundraising/.
DLA Piper. FTC AI Washing Action Underscores Enforcement in Business to Business Context. May 2026. https://www.dlapiper.com/en-us/insights/publications/2026/05/ftc-ai-washing-action-underscores-enforcement-in-business-to-business-context.
Debevoise and Plimpton. AI Enforcement Starts with Washing: The SEC Charges Its First AI Fraud Cases. March 2024. https://www.debevoise.com/insights/publications/2024/03/ai-enforcement-starts-with-washing-the-sec-charges.
Fox Horan and Camerini LLP. Enforcement News: SEC Charges Founder of Joonko with Perpetrating an Old School Fraud Using New School Buzzwords. https://fhnylaw.com/enforcement-news-sec-charges-founder-of-joonko-with-perpetrating-an-old-school-fraud-using-new-school-buzzwords/.
J.S. Held. AI Washing and the Imperative for Board Governance. 2026. https://www.jsheld.com/insights/articles/ai-washing-and-the-imperative-for-board-governance.
The D&O Diary. Tech Exec Charged with AI Washing Related Securities Fraud. April 2025. https://www.dandodiary.com/2025/04/articles/securities-enforcement/tech-exec-charged-with-ai-washing-related-securities-fraud/.
White and Case. Evolution of AI Washing Enforcement: DOJ Enters the Picture. 2026. https://www.whitecase.com/insight-alert/evolution-ai-washing-enforcement-doj-enters-picture.
Interested in analysis about the intersection of tech, policy and the law? Check out my Substack channel. https://theinnovationattorney.substack.com/